How to pitch a website redesign when the site is broken
Tell a local business owner their website is broken without shaming them. You get wording for each problem our check finds and the mistakes to avoid.
A good pitch to a business with a broken website is one true sentence about what is wrong, said kindly, followed by a small offer. The time to pitch a website redesign comes later, once the owner has seen the problem and seen that you are the person who noticed it. This post is our advice on how to do that, and we cannot promise it will get you work.
Check it yourself first
Before you contact anyone, open the website on your own phone and on a computer. If you are working from a Company Finders file, each row has the date we checked the website, and a site that was down on that day may be back up today. If it is fixed, cross the business off or pick a different reason to talk.
Read the finding with care too. Our file has a result called "could not check", which means the site turned our checker away. We never call that broken, and you should never pitch it as broken.
Say what a customer sees
Owners rarely know what a certificate or a server error is. They do know what it looks like when a customer cannot reach them, so turn the finding into what a person sees on their screen.
| What we found | What a customer sees | A way to say it |
|---|---|---|
| Web address not found | The browser says the site cannot be found | "When I type in your web address, my browser says it cannot find the site." |
| Home page not found | A "page not found" message | "Your web address opens a 'page not found' message where your home page should be." |
| Server error | An error message, no site | "Your site showed an error page when I opened it this morning." |
| Security certificate expired or not valid | A warning before the site opens | "My browser shows a security warning before it will open your site." |
| No answer after four tries | A page that never loads | "I tried your site a few times and it never finished loading." |
| Not built for phones | Small text that needs zooming | "On my phone I had to zoom in to read your site." |
| Footer shows an old year | A date from years ago at the bottom | "The year at the bottom of your site is a few years old." |
| Parked or placeholder page | A holding page, not the business | "Your web address shows a holding page, not your business." |
| Only a social media page | The Website button opens Facebook | "The website link on your Google listing goes to your Facebook page." |
| One of Google's free business sites | A link to a site Google shut down in 2024 | "Your listing still points to one of the free Google sites. Google shut those down in 2024." |
The left column covers most of what our checker marks as broken or out of date. The full list, and how each one is decided, is on how we check websites.
Lead with the fact, then ask
Put the fact first and your offer second. Whether it is a phone call, a visit or a note, say who you are and that you are local, say the one thing you found in the customer's words, and ask a question.
For example: "Hi, I'm Sam, I build websites here in Austin. I tried to open your website this morning and my browser showed a security warning. Did you know about that?"
Then stop talking, because the answer tells you what to do next. The owner might say they know, or that someone looks after the site, or that they had no idea.
Plan to reach them by phone or in person. We read email addresses from a site's home page, and when a site is down there may be no home page to read, so a broken row may have no email in the file. For phone wording, see a cold call opener for each thing we find.
Make the first offer small
Someone who has just learned their website is down wants the problem to go away before they will look at a proposal for a full rebuild. These first offers are small and easy to say yes to:
- "I can send you a screenshot of what I see, so you can pass it to whoever looks after the site."
- "I can take a look and tell you what has gone wrong."
- "If nobody looks after it now, I can get it back up for you."
A redesign is a fair thing to raise once you have helped, or once the owner tells you the site has been neglected for years. Let them get there.
What not to do
- Do not shame them. "Your website is terrible" ends the call, while "Your site would not open for me" starts one.
- Do not guess at lost money. You do not know how many customers a broken site has cost, so do not put a number on it.
- Do not call a site broken if you have not seen it fail yourself today.
- Do not pretend to be a customer. Say who you are and what you do.
- Do not send the same message to everyone. The reason to contact this business is the thing you found on this business's site.
What you are likely to find
We cannot tell you how common each problem is in general, but we can show you one real search. On 17 November 2026 we visited 200 websites of plumbers within 25 km of Austin, Texas, and 13 were broken: 4 with the home page not found, 4 with the web address not found, 2 with no answer, 2 with server errors and 1 with a bad certificate.
A further 9 still showed an old year, 5 were not built for phones, 4 were parked or expired domains and 1 was a Facebook page only. Another 33 could not be checked and 135 loaded with nothing to report. That is one trade, in one city, on one day, so take it as a picture of what a list can hold and not as a rate.
When they already know
Some owners will say "yes, I know, I keep meaning to fix it". That is not a no, so ask what has stopped them, which may be time or not knowing who to ask.
Some will say a relative or a friend looks after the site, in which case offer the screenshot and leave your number. You have been useful, and that is a fine place to stop. Others will not want to talk, so thank them and move on to the next row.
The list itself is described on businesses with broken websites, and the wider plan is in how to sell websites to local businesses. To find broken and out-of-date sites in your own trade and city, start on the search.
Updated 18 Nov 2026.
More guides
- A cold call opener for web designers that leads with a factStart a cold call with one true fact about the owner's website and a question. This guide has the wording for each thing our check finds.
- How to find businesses without websitesWe compare three ways to find local businesses with no website, show what one real search returned, and list four mistakes to avoid.
- How to open CSV in Excel or Google SheetsOpen your Company Finders CSV file in Excel or Google Sheets without losing phone numbers or postcodes, then sort, filter and work through the list.
- How to sell websites to local businesses in seven stepsPick one trade, build a list where every business has a reason to hear from you, look before you call, and make a small, clear first offer.
- What it means if a business has no website on Google MapsThis guide explains what a Google Maps listing with no website tells you about a business, what it leaves out, and how to check before you call.
Also useful
- Broken and out-of-date websites that need a redesignSee which local businesses in a trade and city have a website that is down, not built for phones or years out of date, with the date we checked.
- Local SEO leads with the first checks already doneThis list puts one trade in one area on one sheet and shows which businesses have no website, a broken one, few reviews or an unclaimed Google profile.
- B2B Lead Finder alternative without a subscriptionB2B Lead Finder is a monthly workspace with scores, audit reports and a CRM. Company Finders is one file of an area's businesses, paid for once.
See how many are near youChoose a trade and a city. The count is free, and you see the price before you decide whether to buy the list.