Company Finders

How to check a local business website in five minutes before you call

Six checks you can run on a local business's website before you call, what each one tells you, and what you can honestly say on the call afterwards.

Written by the Company Finders team, who sell the lists this guide mentions, and updated on 20 Nov 2026. The figures are our own counts, each with its date, and the advice is our own.

Before you call a local business about its website, open the site yourself on your phone and on a computer, and run six quick checks: does it open, is there a security warning, does it fit a phone screen, how old is the footer year, is it a real site or only a social page, and do the phone number and hours match the Google listing. We suggest giving it about five minutes, which is enough to find one true sentence to start the call with. This post goes through each check, says what it does and does not tell you, and gives the wording that matches it.

These are the same signs our checker reads when it opens a website for a list, so a row in a Company Finders file has usually done most of this for you. You should still look yourself, because a website can change between the day we checked it and the day you call.

1. Does it open at all?

Type the address from the listing into your phone's browser, not a search engine, so you see what a customer who taps the link sees. If you get "this site can't be reached", a "page not found" error or a server error, try once more a few minutes later before you count it. Our checker asks twice before it calls a domain missing, and retries a server error, because sites often have a bad minute.

A site that does not open is the strongest reason to call, and it is also the one you most need to double-check. Say what a customer sees: "When I tapped the website on your Google listing, the page didn't open."

2. Is there a security warning?

If the browser shows a full-page warning saying the connection is not private, a customer has to click past an alarming message to reach the business. This usually means the site's certificate has expired or was issued for another address. Not every owner knows what a certificate is, so describe the warning, not the cause: "My phone showed a warning saying the site might not be safe."

A small "not secure" label in the address bar, with no full-page warning, is a lesser problem. It means the site has no secure (https) version, which our checker marks as out of date rather than broken.

3. Does it fit a phone screen?

Open the site on your phone and hold it upright. If you have to pinch and scroll sideways to read it, or the text is tiny and the buttons too small to tap, the site was built for computers only. An owner can see this for themselves on their own phone in a few seconds, which makes it an easy fact to share.

On the call, offer to show them: "On my phone the page shows the desktop version, so the text is very small."

Scroll to the bottom of the home page and look for a copyright line, such as "© 2019". An old year on its own is a weak sign, because some sites never update the footer even when the rest is current. It means more beside another sign, such as a site that does not fit a phone or a news page that stops years ago. Our checker counts a footer year as out of date only when it is five or more years old, or three or more years old beside another sign.

Do not open the call with the footer year alone. Use it as a second fact once the conversation has started.

5. Is it a website, or only a social page?

Some listings link to a Facebook or Instagram page instead of a website. Others link to a parked domain, a "domain for sale" page, or a website builder's "reconnect your domain" page, which means the owner's site has lapsed. Some still link to one of Google's free business sites. MarTech reported on 10 Jan 2024 that Google would turn these sites off that March (MarTech, 10 Jan 2024). Open that link too: if the page does not load, or only sends you on to Google Maps or a Google search, the business has no working site of its own.

Each of these is a true and specific fact you can see for yourself, and the last one may be news to the owner: "I tried the website link on your Google listing today and it took me back to Google, not to a site of your own."

6. Do the details match the Google listing?

Compare the phone number, address and opening hours on the website with the business's Google Maps listing. If they differ, a customer may call a dead number or arrive when the shop is shut. You cannot tell which one is wrong, so ask rather than tell: "The hours on your website and on your Google listing are different. Which ones are right?"

Our checker does not run this check, so it is worth doing by hand.

What a clean result means

If the site opens, has no warning, fits a phone and the details match, there may be nothing to sell on this call, and that is useful to know before you dial. Cross the business off or pick a different reason to talk. A row marked "loads fine" in our file means the home page loaded and we found none of the faults we look for. We look at the home page only, so it is not a full review of the site.

If our file says "could not check", it means we could not find out that day, perhaps because the site turned automated visitors away or did not answer in time. Never pitch that as broken. Open it yourself and see.

Write down what you saw

Note what you found and the date in the same sheet you call from, next to the business's row, so you remember on a second call what you said on the first. If you work from our file, the result, what we found and the date we checked are already in their own columns, and how to open the file in Excel or Google Sheets shows how to sort and filter it.

What to say next

Once you have one true sentence, the rest of the call is about the owner, not the website. The cold call opener for web designers has openers for each finding, and how to pitch a business with a broken website covers what to say when they already know.

Questions

Is there a tool that checks many websites at once?

Yes. When you buy a Company Finders list, our checker opens the home page of every listed website in that list on the day you order and marks each one broken, out of date, could not check or loads fine, with what it saw. The details are on how we check websites. The same check can be run on a single website through the API.

How long does the check take?

By hand, we suggest allowing about five minutes per business once you know what to look for. Our checker takes one to three minutes for a whole list.

Should I tell the owner their site is bad?

Our advice is no. Tell them what a customer sees, such as a page that does not open or a warning on the screen, and let them decide what it means, because a fact is easier to hear than a verdict.

To have every listed website in one trade near you opened and checked for you, start on the search. Our checker takes one to three minutes for a whole list. The count is free, and a list costs $3 per 1,000 businesses, $1 at the least and $6 at most, paid once by card with no account.

Updated 20 Nov 2026.

More guides

Also useful

See how many are near youChoose a trade and a city. The count is free, and you see the price before you decide whether to buy the list.